Thursday, June 13, 2024
HomeBeautyBest Cream Eyeshadow for Mature Eyes

Best Cream Eyeshadow for Mature Eyes

Mature eyes require a special touch, and eyeshadow can be one of the most finicky products to work with. Wrinkling and hooded eyes can require a different type of formula from what you may have been wearing in your earlier makeup days. If you use the wrong type of eyeshadow it can set into creases and potentially make your eyes look older than they are.

Color, vibrancy, consistency, and texture are all important considerations when looking for a cream shadow. Overall, you just want a great wearability factor. You want a great pigment that is going to stay put. Cream eyeshadows are notoriously guilty for sliding around, but our team did the research and came up with the best cream eyeshadow options for mature eyes.

Top 6 Cream Eyeshadows:

  1. e.l.f. Cosmetics Smudge Pot Cream Eyeshadow – $8.99

If you’re ballin’ on a budget, this is the cream eyeshadow for you. Highly pigmented and easily buildable, this shadow gives you an ombre look with a tad of metallic sheen. This gives you a dimensional look with just a few swipes. This is super rich and color and you can apply it quite easily with your fingertips. 

The smooth gel formula is enriched with vitamin E so you are also hydrating your delicate eye area. It’s only $8.99 and it comes in a ton of different colors.

  1. Tom Ford Cream Color for Eyes – $46

A master of makeup, Tom Ford’s cream color for eyes is so chic and gives you a lustrous glow. Eyes are illuminated with eight different pigments and all are metallic shades. It won’t sit in your creases and definitely won’t smudge. 

This long-wearing formula stays effortless on your face all day long. This one and done color also help contour eyes as well. The cream feels quite versatile, but it’s going to cost ya – at $46, this is one of the fancier eyeshadows available.

  1. Nudestix Magnetic Luminous Eye Color – $26

Upon discovering Nudestix, it’s safe to say that this is our new obsession. Not just for mature eyes, this magnetic eye color comes in satin or matte. It wears for 24 hours, it’s waterproof and gives you super precise lining. Eyeshadow pencils certainly aren’t new, but this is easily our favorite. It brightens just right and gives your eye a pop of color without being too much. This is smoother than velvet and gives you a great color payoff. 

You can even wear it while you’re working out and it won’t go anywhere! You can pick this up at Sephora for $26.

  1. RMS Beauty Eye Polish – $28

If you’re looking for an organic option, this RMS Beauty Eye Polish is your best bet. A lot of people who don’t like wearing eyeshadow love this option. The color actually intensifies as the day goes on and it holds onto the lid for dear life. This radiant cream eyeshadow is formulated with nourishing, natural pigments that provide a modern, light-reflective finish. 

Coconut oil, jojoba oil, and vitamin E all combine to soften and soothe the eyes. A favorite among the more mature crowd, this product is truly clean beauty. You can snag it for $28.

  1. Stila Glitter & Glow Liquid Eye Shadow – $24

If you’re a fan of glitter – which, who isn’t – Stila is the best of the bunch. This Glitter & Glow eyeshadow comes in six fun shades. This is the perfect mix of pearl and glitter to lavish eyes with incredible luster. With its uniquely lightweight, water-infused texture, it glides on effortlessly, then dries down smoothly, locking in maximum sparkle with minimal fallout, for eyes with a real “wow!” factor. 

It has a ton of great reviews and fans say it gives their eyes a magic pop. It’s long-wearing and buildable, depending on how much sparkle you’re after. The heavy pigment is absolutely stunning and it’s paraben- and phthalate-free. At $24, you’re going to love the way your eyes shimmer.

  1. Rituel de Fille Ash & Ember Eye Soot – $38

Layering is super simple with this Rituel de Fille Ash & Ember Eye Soot! Yes, it’s called soot, but there is nothing but the intense, smoldering, lasting color here. This rich, powdery cream comes in 12 hues to compliment any eye color. 

Consistently scoring high ratings, mature eyes love this formula because it doesn’t feel waxy and won’t melt into the skin. The pot of rich pigment is highly versatile and some even use it as eyeliner. At $38 per color, this product will stretch away so you’ll definitely get your money’s worth. Your eyes won’t look or feel sooty at all!


Mature eyes can react to certain shadows differently, which is why there is such a market for creating and finding the right one for you. We’re confident that the list we provided can land you a cream eyeshadow you will love and add to your already beautiful eyes.

Most Popular